Emotive Brand’s Take on the iPhone X Design: Color Us Skeptical

iPhone X

iPhone X: Revolutionary or Not

We’re a design studio, so it’s a given that Emotive Brand people are Apple fanboys. We followed the iPhone X launch enthusiastically and our collective hearts beat a little faster when Tim Cook announced the most revolutionary new product since the first iPhone hit the market.

But as iPhone X’s new features were revealed, the collective air went out of the team — not just for the product, but also a bit for the Apple brand. The product definitely struck us as evolutionary, not revolutionary. And a brand that is beloved for over-delivering needs to be extra careful about over-promising.

Apple, we tell you this with love. We know that your innovations are designed to be so forward-looking that it can take people awhile to catch up. Maybe that will be true for us with the iPhone X. Maybe time and eventual usage will make us eat our words.

But at this point, we feel the iPhone X sacrifices too much for the sake of appearing bleeding edge. We’re marketers, but we still don’t like it when it feels like our favorite tech lifestyle company puts marketing ahead of product. As brand people, this makes us worry about one of our favorite companies.

It’s early days for this phone, but here is our perspective on both the hardware design and the user experience design of the iPhone X.

Inelegant Bump-Out

The “revolutionary” edge-to-edge glass (which Samsung has offered for awhile) does provide a bigger screen, and that’s great. But the camera bump-out at the top is inelegant and, worse, gets in the way of content playing on the phone.

We actually prefer the look of a straight frame at the top of the phone, even if it makes the screen minimally smaller. And compromising the viewership experience for the sake of making an edge-to-edge glass claim seems to put marketing ahead of function.

Touch ID Versus Facial Recognition

We love touch ID. You can use it in the dark, in your car, no matter what you’re doing. We’re dubious about facial recognition. What if we’re driving and need to quickly access a map? Will the iPhone X really recognize our face when we check email first thing in the morning, with head half smooshed into the pillow and only one eye open? TouchID can handle those scenarios.

Matt Burns of TechCrunch says this is a deal killer for him. He says Apple tried putting the TouchID sensor on glass, but “couldn’t pull off the trick.” Many Android phones put the sensor on the back, but Apple decided to leave it off.

Security is another compromise. “Apple always wants its user experience to be delightful,” says security expert Marc Rogers in Wired. “In the security world that means you’re going to have to accept certain limitations.”

Again, this strikes us as a sacrifice of form over function akin to other Apple decisions like the elimination of a headphone jack from iPhone 7, forcing the use of wireless earbuds. We hope we’re wrong, but facial recognition seems like a questionable fix for something that already works really well.

$1,000+ Pricetag

Given our skepticism about the key new features of the iPhone X, none of us are planning to run out and plunk down $1,000+ for it. Of course, the sheer beauty of the device might make us reach for our wallets when we see it in person, but given that about 80 percent of iPhone owners use a case, $1,000 is a lot to pay for beauty that you then cover up.

Emotive Brand is a San Francisco Brand Strategy and Design and Agency.

Comments (18)

  1. Everything is good except the display. It has got some bugs which will create some issues with the screen. But Apple will soon resolve it.

  2. Are you experiencing some minor technical issues with your iPhone or iPad? If yes, then there is no need to press the panic button and frantically try to contact the company or the dealer. You have arrived in the right place. We are the number one technical support agency operating in the country. We provide the highest-quality Apple support to our customers.

  3. We are the leading technical support agency operating in the country. All you have to do is to contact our Apple customer care center and talk to our qualified engineer.

  4. Are you using an iPhone or a Mac? If yes, you must be a happy and satisfied consumer because these are world-class products with exciting features. Don’t panic when your phone or laptop begins to malfunction because of a minor technical glitch. Use our Apple help phone number to get rid of these problems.

  5. Are you using an iPhone or a Mac? If yes, you must be a happy and satisfied consumer because these are world-class products with exciting features. Don’t panic when your phone or laptop begins to malfunction because of a minor technical glitch. Use our Apple help phone number to get rid of these problems.

  6. We are the most loved and highly trusted technical support agency nationwide. We have a team of qualified and talented engineers to solve the problems of our customers using iPhones. Contact our iPhone support center today and get authentic resolutions for all your issues.

  7. We are the leading technical support agency in the country. Contact us and explain your issues related to Amazon Prime to our representative. He will give authentic resolutions to your issues. Hundreds of customers have benefitted from our Amazon Prime help in the last few months.

  8. Amazon Kindle is an amazing E-reader that allows its users to enjoy reading books on the go. Are you facing charging issues with your Kindle? Does it create problems during start-up? No matter what the issue, get it resolved by using our popular Amazon Kindle help.

  9. Amazon Kindle is an amazing E-reader that allows its users to enjoy reading books on the go. Are you facing charging issues with your Kindle? Does it create problems during start-up? No matter what the issue, get it resolved by using our popular Amazon Kindle help.

  10. We run the most popular tech support agency in the country. We have hundreds of satisfied customers elated with our high-quality iPhone help. Contact us to get in touch with our experienced engineers. They will give authentic resolutions for all your problems related to your iPhone.

  11. Are you unable to use one or more features of your iPhone? Do you experience some technical issues with your smartphone? If yes, then there is no need to worry. You can get rid of all such problems with the help of our popular and reliable Apple iPhone support.

  12. Apple products are a source of pride and delight for their owners. They are backed by state-of-the-art technology. Are you experiencing some trouble with your Mac,iPad, or iPhone recently, and these products are out of warranty? If yes, there is no need to worry. You don’t need to wait for a long time for the company to respond to your request. Use our Apple customer care number and get rid of all your problems related to Apple products without any delay.

  13. Apple claims to have a robust support system in place for its customers. However, once your Apple product goes out of warranty, getting support from the company at a reasonable cost is not easy. This is where our iPhone support number comes in handy for customers.

  14. It is not easy to get support for your out-of-warranty iPhone from the company. If you don’t like the idea of waiting for a long time and spending a fortune on your old iPhone, you have come to the right place. Simply use our Apple iPhone support number to save your time and money.

  15. We are the most popular and trusted technical support agency providing service to our customers. Our Apple helpline remains open all the time on all seven days of the week. You can reach us anytime you desire and talk tour representative. We will provide the most authentic and effective resolution to your issues related to Apple products.

  16. We are the most popular technical support agency in the country. We provide the highest-quality Amazon Fire tablet customer service. All you need to do is contact us on our toll-free number. Our qualified engineer will provide authentic and long-lasting resolutions to all your issues related to Amazon Fire.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *